Rosters6 min read

Looking for a Deputy alternative? Start with how you are being charged

Deputy is good software. The problem small venues run into is not the product, it is the shape of the bill: it is priced per user, with a minimum monthly spend, so a three-person café pays close to what a ten-person one does. This is how to work out whether you need what you are paying for — and the honest list of what you give up by leaving.

Last updated

The short answer

If you roster a small team and mostly need a roster — build it, share it, let people tell you when they cannot work — a flat-price tool will do the job for less. If you need award interpretation, timesheets that feed payroll, or HR records, you need Deputy or something like it, and this page should not talk you out of it.

The question is not which is better. It is whether you are buying a rostering tool or a workforce-management platform, because you are currently paying for the second.

What Deputy costs a small team

Read off Deputy's Australian pricing page on 18 October 2026. Prices are per user per month, in AUD, excluding tax. Check the current figures before deciding — this is a snapshot, not a quote.

The line that catches small venues is the last one. Deputy's FAQ states a minimum monthly spend of A$30 per invoice on monthly Lite, Core and Pro plans, effective 1 September 2025. Below about four or five staff, the per-user price stops mattering: you pay the minimum either way.

  • Payroll, HR, Messaging+ and Analytics+ are priced as add-ons, also per user per month
  • No free tier is listed; a free trial is offered instead
  • Figures checked 18 October 2026 on deputy.com/au/pricing — confirm before you switch
Deputy planPer user / month3 staff5 staff10 staff
LiteA$6.75A$30 (minimum)A$33.75A$67.50
CoreA$8.75A$30 (minimum)A$43.75A$87.50
ProA$13.00A$39.00A$65.00A$130.00

What a flat price changes

Regentflow Pro is A$29.99 a month, in AUD, whatever the headcount. There is no per-user line, so the bill does not move when you take on three casuals for summer. There is also a A$5 day pass, which exists for the operator who builds a roster once a fortnight and does not want a subscription for it, and a free tier that never expires.

Those figures were read off our own pricing page on the same day, and they are the live ones — if they change, that page changes with them.

Shape of the bill3 staff10 staff
Deputy CorePer user, A$30/mo minimumA$30.00A$87.50
Regentflow ProFlat, unlimited staffA$29.99A$29.99
Regentflow Day PassA$5 for 24 hours, nothing renewsA$5.00A$5.00

What you give up — read this part

Deputy does a great deal that Regentflow does not, and most of it is the reason it costs what it costs. If any of the following is load-bearing for you, switching would be a downgrade, not a saving.

  • Award interpretation — Deputy reads modern awards and applies penalty rates. We do not. Our penalty-rates guide explains the rules; it does not calculate them for you.
  • Timesheets and clock-in — no kiosk, no geofenced punch, no approval workflow here
  • Payroll integration — Deputy feeds payroll systems directly; we export to Excel, CSV and PDF
  • HR records, leave management, onboarding documents and labour-cost forecasting
  • Multi-site scheduling at scale — we are built for one venue, not a group

What you keep

The parts of rostering a small venue actually does every week are all here, and they are the parts a spreadsheet does badly.

  • Build a week, copy it forward, and let the sheet total the paid hours rather than typing them
  • Send staff a link to set their own availability up to four weeks ahead — no account needed
  • Live sync, so the roster on everyone's phone is the one you just changed
  • Export to Excel, CSV or PDF, and print it for the wall
  • Every free tool as well — invoices, quotes, cost sheets, PDF Studio

An honest way to decide

Open your last Deputy invoice and look at two numbers: what you paid, and how many of the features on it you touched that month. If the answer is "the roster and nothing else", the per-user bill is buying you optionality you are not using.

Then try the other one for a day. A$5 is a cheaper way to find out than a migration, and if the answer is that you need the award engine, you have lost five dollars and settled the question.

Or let Smart Roster do it

Build the roster, send staff a link to set their own availability, and let the sheet add the hours up. Flat price, however many staff you put on it.

Questions

Is Regentflow a drop-in replacement for Deputy?
No. It replaces the rostering and availability parts. It does not do award interpretation, timesheets, clock-in or payroll, so if you rely on those, it is not a replacement and we would rather say so now.
How much does Deputy cost in Australia?
On 18 October 2026 Deputy's AU pricing page listed Lite at A$6.75, Core at A$8.75 and Pro at A$13 per user per month, excluding tax, with add-ons priced separately and a stated minimum monthly spend of A$30 per invoice on monthly plans. Check their page for current pricing before deciding.
Is there a free way to try it?
Yes. The free tier never expires and includes unlimited invoices and quotes, cost sheets, PDF Studio and the calculators, with 5 AI credits to try the scanning. Smart Roster is a Pro tool, so the cheapest way to test rostering properly is the A$5 day pass.
Does it handle penalty rates?
No. It totals hours; it does not price them against an award. Our penalty-rates guide explains how the rules work and points at the Fair Work source, which is the right place to confirm anything that affects someone's pay.
Can staff set their own availability?
Yes — you send a link or a code and they set shifts up to four weeks ahead without creating an account. That is the part most small venues are actually chasing when they go looking for rostering software.